Are Milk Bar Cakes Worth It

Must Try

How Does It Taste

Baking and Testing Milk Bar’s Birthday Cake Recipe (Worth it?)

This isnt your average cake. If youve never tried the 6-inch Milk Bar Birthday Cake, you might think it wont be enough for celebrating with more than one or two other people. It looks kind of small, you might say to yourself. I could take this down faster than you can sing two rounds of Happy Birthday. But you would be mistaken.

With three spongy, rainbow sprinkle-infused yellow cake layers, each held together with thick, cream cheese-tinged vanilla frosting, then topped with more frosting and dotted with crunchy cake crumbs , it’s deceivingly dense, and easily serves 8 to 12 people.

What To Actually Try At The Milk Bar Flagship

Cereal Milk: Best sampled either as cool soft serve or as actual sweet-salty milk the latter is off-menu but available.

Peppermint snaps: A chocolate wafer layered with caramel and pretzels, dipped in white chocolate peppermint bark each flavor comes through clearly without devolving into heavy sweetness .

Birthday cake or corn truffles: Small snacky bites flavored like vanilla cake or vegetal corn and caramel. Eat them cold .

Apple pie soft serve : The texture is a bit thin, but it packs a wallop of cider flavor .

Cerealsies: Try the spicy cinnamon-sugar spheres or the Andes-like mint variety . Avoid the birthday flavor.

Milk Bar pie: A riff on chess pie that tames buttery, sugary goodness with an oat crust .

Strawberry corn Milkquake: A slightly soupy mix of Cereal Milk soft serve with fragrant pickled strawberries and salty cake bites .

Chocolate cookies: Underbaked , but with enough chocolate and salt to counterbalance the sugars .

Anyone whos ever encountered a bagel bite at a coffee chain, Fruit Loop-flavored ice cream at a grocery store, or unironic funfetti desserts can send Tosi a thank-you note. Milk Bars influence is nothing less than immense.

Clockwise from top left: A large cookie cake with pretzels, a racks of exposed cakes, and bagel bombs

Taste And Texture: Cake

Ive heard of these people that use cake simply as a vehicle for frosting. Somehow, these individuals walk the earth without appreciation for a perfectly textured slice of spongy cake. I, however, am not one of those people. I. Love. Cake.

And although I picked this dessert up in Toronto, its my understanding that all Milk Bar products are actually flown in from NYC. So obviously, time and distance factor in the quality of consumed product. Having heard so much hype about this cake, I had very high expectations. And knowing the deliciousness of other Milk Bar desserts, the bar raised even higher. However, when the time came to bite into the slice of presumed heaven, l have to admit I was disappointed.

Now, this is not to say that the cake was so dry that an avalanche of crumbs tumbled to my plate. But the moist, freshness that give cakes that ever-so-desirable quality was seriously lacking. However Im, chalking this up to sheer travel distance . I mean, after a long road trip, people arent exactly at peak quality either.

Cake texture earned a respectable 3.5 out of from me this round.

Recommended Reading: Gluten Free Cake Recipes From Scratch

Puppy Birthday Cake Recipe: How To Make It

Prepare for baking: Preheat the oven to 350°F and grease an 8-inch cake pan or an 8×4-inch loaf pan and set aside. Mix dry ingredients: In a medium bowl whisk together the flour and baking soda. Add the wet ingredients: Next add the peanut butter, vegetable oil, honey, carrots, and egg.

dog treats for decoration Heres how you do it: For the cake- Preheat your oven to 350 degree F. Prepare an 8 inch round pan w ith by greasing with oil. In a bowl, mix flour and baking soda then set aside. In another bowl, mix vegetable oil, 1/2 cup of the peanut butter, White House Foods® A pplesauce, and the canned pumpkin puree.

Dog Cupcakes, also called Pupcakes, are a fun treat for your favorite furry friend! Based off of my wildly popular Spoiled Dog Cake recipe, these fun cupcakes are a great way to celebrate your pups birthday, gotcha day, or just a way to show them how much you love them!

This dog birthday cake recipe is a simple dessert that will satisfy your furry friend to celebrate their special occasion. Its made using easy ingredients like peanut butter, applesauce, and carrots and its completely dog safe. Its the best homemade birthday cake that a dog can eat, perfect for your pups birthday.

PREHEAT oven to 350 degrees F. Place 1 or 2 paper liners into a muffin pan. Recipe makes one large cupcake or 2 medium sized cupcakes. WHISK together pumpkin, peanut butter, and oats in the bottom of a small bowl. MIX in the egg and baking powder until incorporated.

What Is Milk Bar

[homemade] Milk Bar Birthday Cake : food

Christina Tosi opened the first Milk Bar in 2008.

Famed pastry chef Christina Tosi opened her first bakery in New York City in 2008, selling inventive, offbeat treats like Compost Cookies , Cereal Milk Soft Serve , and the cult favorite Milk Bar Pie.

More than a decade later, Milk Bar now operates bakeries in New York City, Los Angeles, Boston, and beyond, and ships its baked goods all over the country. Packaged cookies have also started popping up on shelves at nationwide retailers.

Besides her cookies and soft serve, some of Tosis most popular creations include delightful layer cakes and cake trufflesbites of cake coated with a super-thin layer of chocolate and rolled in sand, which is a super fine mix of sugar, flour, and baking powder.

Also Check: Where Can I Buy A Diaper Cake

Milk Bar Birthday Cake

When you order a Milk Bar Cake, it comes carefully wrapped and insulated with freezer packs in a cooler. You can store it in the fridge for up to 7 days , or in the freezer for 30 days . I ordered the Milk Bar Birthday Cake because I knew for sure that it was AMAZING! I also ordered the Milk Bar Chocolate Malt Bar Cake because I love chocolate and wanted to also try something new.

This is how the cakes looked when they came out of the box. They are securely wrapped and protected.

I ordered the two cakes as a special surprise for a dinner party that would be 3 days later. Therefore, I stored them in my refrigerator until I was ready to serve them for the dinner party.

*UPDATE*: I apparently unwrapped the cakes upside down. Each side has a card board cover top. I unpacked them how they came out of the box. I had no idea I was doing it wrong… but had I known better, the top would have had a pretty layer of cookie crumbs! Whoops! None the less, the cake tasted extraordinary upside down or right side up!

Because the cakes were shipped from such a distance and came frozen, I was curious to see how they would compare to the homemade fresh cake that my friend talentedly put together. I was not disappointed in any way.

Burning During The War Of 1812

On August 2425, 1814, in a raid known as the , British forces invaded the capital during the . The , , and were burned and gutted during the attack. Most government buildings were repaired quickly however, the Capitol was largely under construction at the time and was not completed in its current form until 1868.

Read Also: 8 Inch Round Nonstick Cake Pan

Somilk Bar: The Verdict

Okay, here we go.

First thought: the original Milk Bar location is so charmingly unassuming. Its a tiny little shop that can only fit about a handful of people inside to place an orderno indoor seating. Thankfully there wasnt a line out the door to orderin fact, we were the only people ordering when we arrived. There was a steady stream of people who came and went while we sat outside, but the place wasnt exactly hopping at around 2pm on a Saturday afternoon. That initially surprised me, but then I remembered that the NYC nightlife is strong, and the shops posted hours are 9am-1am, so doubtless many people hit up Milk Bar in the evening hours.

What did we try? The Birthday Cake, obviously. Also, Birthday Cake Truffles, Corn Cookie, and Compost Cookie Soft Serve. We also sampled the Compost Cookie and Cereal Milk Soft Serve. Im kicking myself for not ordering a slice of Crack Pie, but at the time it seemed exorbitant. In quantity of sweets to eat, yes, but also in price. The slice of cake alone was $9!

The cookies, both Corn and Compost, were yummy.

The ice cream wasstrange. We each had our different takes. The Compost Cookie soft serve has a chocolate pretzel soft serve base that I found nearly inedible on its ownit was just way too saltybut that was mitigated by the sweet and crunchy Compost Cookie topping. And thats exactly Christina Tosis trademark: marrying dynamic textures with super salty and super sweet to create an addicting treat.

It was neither.

Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow


But, I did try something similar with the Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow !

First, I tried it on its own and WOWZA. I could not get enough of the marshmallow flavor, which was like having ooey gooeyness goodness around the campfire without all the flame, char, and ash! The cookie dough ice cream base really complemented and brought out the mallow. The rest of the ingredients helped to seal the deal. There was great texture from the chocolate chips, which were more like rectangular chunks reminiscent of Ben & Jerrys inclusions.

Additionally, the cornflake crunch was not soggy but not a frozen flake either, so I considered it just right on the texture spectrum. And guess what? They tasted just like cornflakes. Said corn flavor was as comforting as my childhood cereal.

As Milk Bar also sells a grocery-exclusive version of their cookies in the same exact flavor, I decided I would also use them to make an ice cream cookie sandwich. This is not a cookie review, so Ill just concisely say that the ice cream MADE the sandwich the key again being the marshmallow goodness. Id prefer to eat it on its own, though!

Purchased Price: $5.99 Purchased at: Whole Foods Rating: 8 out of 10Nutrition Facts: 300 calories, 19 grams of fat, 11 grams of saturated fat, 0 grams of trans fat, 40 milligrams of cholesterol, 110mg of sodium, 0 grams of fiber, 29 grams of carbohydrates, 20 grams of sugar, and 1 gram of protein.

Recommended Reading: Where To Buy A Birthday Cake For A Dog

Dog Birthday Cake Recipes For Your Pup’s Special Day

Great question, yes, this cake does not need to be baked. Baked goods can upset my dogs system so this is fully cooled in the fridge. It will firm up there but will still have a very soft texture . I give my dog 1/2 of the recipe to start out. I hope this helps, and happy birthday to your dog!

Directions for Dog Birthday Cake with Meat. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. In a large bowl, stir together all of the ingredients. This mixture will be slightly wetter then most, but thats okay. As it cooks, the rice needs to soak up the moisture. I used two mini spring foam pans for our Dog Birthday Cake.

If your dog can’t have peanut butter or just doesn’t like the flavor, try my best dog birthday cake recipe that does not include this ingredient. Birthday cakes are a fun way to celebrate your pooch.

3rd Recipe. Making a dog birthday cake is not so difficult, and even easier than for humans. By the way, you can even eat a slice of such a cake on the birthday of your four-footed friend. Therefore, you can choose a recipe based on your taste preferences. The main thing is that there are no products that are not desirable for the dog.

Much like myself, my dog has a sweet tooth and a salty tooth. So basically, this recipe is perfect for her. It does, however, call for quite a few ingredients. According to the website Parsnips and Pastries, youll need: 1/4 cup peanut butter. 1/2 cup pure unsweetened pumpkin puree. 1/2 cup unsweetened applesauce.

Special Ingredients You Need

There are a handful of ingredients that you may/may not be familiar with:

  • Vegetable shortening. Shortening is mixed together with the butter to make the birthday cake and frosting white, not too yellow.
  • Clear vanilla extract. Milk Bar uses McCormick vanilla extract in the birthday cake, crumbs, and frosting. The taste of imitation vanilla recreates the classic flavor of the cake box mix. Clear vanilla extract also helps the cake components white in color.
  • Grapeseed oil. Grapeseed oil is low in saturated fat and has a light color and flavor that wont conflict with the other flavors in your cake.
  • Glucose. Liquid glucose, often referred to as glucose syrup, is a liquid form of simple sugar. Glucose is added to birthday cake frosting. It keeps the frosting soft and moist. You can substitute glucose with corn syrup, but the frosting will be sweeter.
  • Corn syrup. The corn syrup adds moisture to help dissolve the sugar. It also makes the frosting more glossy and luscious. You can substitute half the amount of corn syrup for glucose by volume.
  • Citric acid. Citric acid is a weak, organic acid naturally found in citrus fruits. It is most often used as a natural preservative or to add an acidic or sour taste to food and baked products. If you cant find any, you can also substitute citric acid for a little amount of lemon juice.

You May Like: Order King Cake Online New Orleans

$15 Shipping On All Orders

How We Deliver Birthday Cakes to Your Door

  • We bake our Birthday Cakes with care and deliver them to your door using our tried-and-true packing methods to ensure a safe delivery.
  • Cakes are wrapped safe and snug in specially designed, insulated packaging .
  • Our shipping partners deliver Monday – Saturday to any domestic address with the exception of U.S. Territories, APO/FPO, P.O. Boxes. Delivery windows are not available.
  • Cake script is available on pick-up orders only. For shipped cakes, you may include a gift note at checkout for an extra-special Birthday Cake delivery!
  • Ordering for an event? We advise having your Birthday Cake delivered one day early see here for storage details.
  • Placing a pick-up order for an extra large 10 Birthday Cake? Reach out to.


6″ cake ingredients:10″ cake ingredients:

Made in a facility that processes PEANUTS AND TREE NUTS

Contains: milk, eggs, wheat, soy

How we make our Birthday Cake:1. Rainbow cake

Special Tools And Equipment

Momofuku Milk Bar Cake : Baking

You will also need to gather these tools and equipment to make this cake:

  • 1 quarter sheet pan. The most important note when it comes to this birthday cake is that you are not going to bake three 6-inch cakes. Instead, you will bake one large sheet cake. Then, you will stamp the 2 cake rounds with a cake ring. For the third cake layer, you will need to put together the remaining off-cuts from the sheet cake.
  • 1 6-inch/15 cm cake ring. A cake ring is used to stamp out the birthday cake. Then, the stamped cake rounds are stacked in the same cake ring lined with an acetate cake collar.
  • 2 strips 3-inch/7.5 cm cake acetate. Cake acetate is a type of sturdy plastic that comes in sheets or rolls. It is used to line the inside of the cake ring. They will serve as a protective wrap for naked cakes.
  • Pastry brush. Use a pastry brush to lightly brush the cake soak into each layer of cake.
  • Bent spoon or small ladle spoon. In many Christina Tosi videos, she uses a bent spoon to spread the frosting. I found using a small ladle spoon works as well.

Don’t Miss: Fresh Peach Cobbler With Cake Mix

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This