Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake

Must Try

How Do I Fix Over

How To Make The Best Ice Cream Cake!

Once over-whipped, the whipped cream will deflate and look curdled. Not to worry, you might be able to save it! Put the mixer on low and slowly drizzle cold heavy cream into the bowl until the whipped cream is fluffy again. You may need anywhere from 2 to 3 tablespoons or half a cup of heavy whipping cream.

How Long To Thaw Ice Cream Cake Before Serving

The taste of ice cream cake is delectable, but trying to take a bite out of a rock-hard ice cream cake is not at all pleasant.Place your ice cream cake in the refrigerator for 30 minutes or leave it out on the counter for 15 minutes to ensure that it is ready to be served to party attendees.Greetings, there!My name is Michelle, and ice cream cake is one of my favorite desserts.The mix of ice cream and cake is something out of which fantasies are created.

It goes without saying that youll want your ice cream cake to have the proper consistency for eating, and that may be difficult to achieve at times.If youre planning a huge party and serving an ice cream cake, its critical to know how long to let the cake thaw before serving it to your guests.All of this information, as well as more details, may be found further down on this page.Whos eager to indulge in a flawlessly thawed ice cream cake with their friends?

Perfect Slice Serving Tips

Each cake or pie will serve around 12 people, depending on slice size.

Thaw in refrigerator for 40-45 mins. prior to serving. This will allow cake to moisten and ice cream to soften.

When cutting, remove cake from plastic tray and place on solid cutting surface. Heat large kitchen knife under hot water. Wipe blade dry between cuts.

Once finished, put leftovers back on tray with dome securely tightened and return to freezer. For best taste consume leftovers within a week.

Also Check: What To Make With Cake Flour

Pro Tips For Making This Recipe

  • Its best to slightly soften the ice cream before adding it to the cake pan so you can create a uniform layer, making it much easier to layer on top of the cake.
  • Be sure to press out any air pockets in the ice cream when adding it to the cake pan.
  • When lining the cake pan for the ice cream, be sure to leave some extra plastic wrap on the sides to make it easier to lift.
  • Try to have your kitchen as cold as possible to make sure the ice cream cake doesnt melt as you work with it. If your kitchen is on the warmer side, youll have to put your cake back into the freezer often in between steps.
  • To make cutting the cake easier, you can run your knife under hot water before slicing.

Add Fudge And Cookie Crumble

Make your own layered ice cream cake with any filling you would like ...

Lauren Habermehl for Taste of Home

Next, pour a generous layer of the chocolate ganache over the chocolate ice cream layer. Smooth with an offset spatula before sprinkling the ganache with the chilled cookie crumbles. Gently smooth out the crumbles to form an even layer. Freeze the chocolate ice cream, fudge and cookie crumble layers for 20-30 minutes until firm.

You May Like: Usa Pan Bakeware Round Cake Pan 8 Inch

What If I Dont Have Powdered Sugar

Granulated sugar can work in a pinch, but sometimes the whipped cream will weep as it loses the air bubbles whipped into the cream at a faster rate when using granulated sugar which is why I prefer powdered sugar. If you use granulated sugar, be sure to consume it immediately! You can also make your own by following my guide on How to Make Powdered Sugar.

Why You’re Going To Love This Ice Cream Cake Recipe

Step By Step Instructions – I’ll be honest, there are a lot of steps to this recipe, and a lot of back and forth from the freezer. I promise it’s worth it, and it’s not difficult at all to make your own ice cream cake.

Amazing Textures – Ice cream cake is an amazing mix of textures from creamy ice cream, thick fudge sauce, and chocolate crunchies. It’s a party in your mouth!

No-Bake Birthday Cake – Perfect for summer birthdays, you can make a fun and delicious birthday ice cream cake without ever turning on the oven.

Customizable – While vanilla and chocolate are the classic flavors of an ice cream cake since you’re making it, you can choose whatever flavors you like! You can also adjust the filling or get creative with the decorations.

Iconic – There are a few things that I can count on when I think about birthdays, and ice cream cake is one of them! Even if you haven’t had ice cream cake since you were a kid, I know you remember how much fun they are.

Also Check: Where To Buy German Chocolate Cake Ice Cream

The Dubious Economics Of Homemade Ice Cream Cakes

But, before we get started, Id like to be completely honest with you.Making an ice cream cake from scratch is not a very cost-effective option, from an economic standpoint.Dairy Queens normal round cakes are priced between $20 and $25 at most locations.Making this with high-quality ice cream and store-bought components, such as fudge sauce and cookies, would almost certainly cost significantly more money than making it from scratch.Of course, saving money isnt the only incentive to make anything from scratch you could also want to utilize your own unique handmade tastes or make a cake with dairy-free ice cream as a special treat.

You could want to make an extra effort to decorate it, or you might want to add some freshly made cookies inside.A word of caution, however: if youre looking for the lowest choice, head to your local supermarket.Proceed for all of the other reasons as well!That being said, let us now discuss how long this will take you to complete your assignment.Making an ice cream cake is not difficult in fact, I would argue that it is easier than baking a cake.

  • The cake is then frosted with whipped cream, and it is best if it is allowed to remain in the freezer for another night before serving.
  • When dealing with ice cream, youre constantly racing against the clock, so allow plenty of time between processes to allow everything to cool down between steps.
  • Last but not least, theres the matter of freezer space.
  • Youll need a lot of it.
  • Birthday Party Ice Cream Cake Near You

    How to Make Your Own Perfect Professional Ice Cream Cake 2

    Nothing makes it a day to remember like one of our Premium Ice Cream Cakes. Handcrafted with love, every cake begins with our super premium ice cream thats made right in our kitchen. We make the ice cream and you make it yours. Choose from mix-ins of delicious fruits, the finest nuts, the sweetest candies and the yummiest cookies. And then well slather it all on top of rich cake for originality by the slice. Because thats how you create mmm-mmm-memory!

    Don’t Miss: How Do You Make An Ice Cream Sandwich Cake

    How To Store And Transport Ice Cream Cake

    This should be considered an extreme sport! As noted above, investing in a simple cake carrier will be your secret to success. Prior to starting your ice cream cake, we recommend clearing an area of your freezer that is large enough to allow the cake carrier to fit and sit level inside. If you have a drawer freezer, make sure your freezer opens wide enough .

    You can safely and successfully transport an ice cream cake using a large cooler or insulated food carrier. The trick is to make sure the vessel you are using is large enough to fit your cake carrier along with several ice packs or bags of ice. For best results, we recommend letting your ice cream cake freeze for 24 hours in the freezer before transporting it to make sure everything is as frozen as possible. We also suggest packing your cake at the very last minute before your departure.

    Dont forget to make sure you have a place to store your cake when you arrive at your destination. Your best bet will be to have a freezer to transfer your ice cream cake to when you arrive to keep it frozen until youre ready to serve.

    Still hungry? Learn more about sweet, cool treats in our ultimate ice cream guide.

    What Is The Easiest Way To Crush Oreos

    You can crush Oreos in a few different ways.

    The fastest way is to put them in your food processor. Pulse until you get fine crumbs.

    Otherwise, place the cookies in a heavy zip-top bag, seal it, and use a meat mallet or a heavy rolling pin to beat them up until you have the right size crumbs. This method takes longer, but its kind of fun!

    Read Also: How To Do A Pie Chart In Excel

    You May Like: 14 Inch White Pedestal Cake Stand

    How To Store A Homemade Ice Cream Cake

    You have ice cream cake leftovers? I’m not sure that’s ever happened in my house! You should obviously store any leftover ice cream cake in the freezer so you can enjoy it later. Wrap it with plastic wrap to keep it from freezer burn or crystalizing. It will be best enjoyed within 7-10 days.

    Avoid letting the ice cream cake soften too much if you plan to re-freeze it.

    If you want to make your ice cream cake ahead of time, it’s easiest to make it minus the whipped cream frosting for storage, then make the frosting and decorate the cake the day you plan to serve it.

    A disposable cake box or a plastic cake taker will be useful for storing your cake in the freezer.

    Create The Bottom Ice Cream Layer

    Make Your Own Ice Cream Cake

    Lauren Habermehl for Taste of Home

    Remove the chocolate ice cream from the freezer and let soften for 15-20 minutes. Once the vanilla ice cream wall has firmed up in the pan, spoon the chocolate ice cream into the center of the cake pan lined with vanilla ice cream. Smooth and level the chocolate ice cream with an offset spatula.

    Don’t Miss: How To Make A Pussy Cake

    Best Ice Cream Cake Flavors

    You can make this classic chocolate and vanilla ice cream cake and everyone will be thrilled, but you can also change up the flavors and add-ins to make a specialty ice cream cake just like Cold Stone Creamery or your favorite local ice cream shops make. Use any of our Homemade Ice Cream Recipes to create your custom ice cream cake.

    Try some of these delicious ice cream cake flavor combinations:

    Cookies and Cream Oreo Ice Cream Cake Use Cookies and Cream ice cream for both the top and bottom layers, and fill with fudge and crushed Oreos.

    Peanut Butter Chocolate Ice Cream Cake Start with a layer of Chocolate ice cream, fill with fudge and chopped Reeses cups, and top with a layer of homemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream. Iced with chocolate ganache, this cake will be so decadent!

    Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Cake One layer of Strawberry Ice Cream and another of Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream. Fill the center with a mix of Golden Oreo crumbs, chopped freeze-dried strawberries, and whipped cream.

    Customized Ice Cream Cake You can choose any two ice cream flavors! Try using Pistachio Ice Cream, Pumpkin Spice Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip Ice Cream or Black Raspberry Ice Cream to make a really unique ice cream cake.

    The Perfect Summer Treat

    Born and raised in Arizona, we are used to VERY hot summers. But even though we have become accustomed to them, we still like to have plenty of cool desserts to help us survive them!

    One of our favorites is ice cream cake, and especially todays Cookies and Cream Oreo Ice Cream Cake.

    This ice cream cake is delicious and super easy to make. If youve tried our Dirt Cake and love Oreos, then I think youll love this one too. The recipe reminded me of the Dirt cake with all the Oreos, which made it really familiar and really yummy. and perfect to keep us cool in the hot Arizona heat.

    Don’t Miss: Order Cake From Sam’s Club

    Ice Cream Cake Recipe

    Homemade ice cream cake can be made with store-bought ice cream, or you can use your homemade flavors in this recipe. The basic recipe calls for Vanilla ice cream and Chocolate ice cream. You can also use Vanilla Bean Ice Cream. Keep reading for more ice cream flavor options.

    For an Italian spin on this classic ice cream dessert, try making Semifreddo next.

    Want a festive celebration ice cream recipe that is a bit easier than making a whole ice cream cake? Try making Sprinkles Ice Cream or Birthday Cake Ice Cream instead.

    Funfetti Ice Cream works too. For another traditional classic, make a Banana Split.

    This is a Dairy Queen ice cream cake copycat recipe! It’s got layers of chocolate and vanilla ice cream, sandwiching a sweet and gooey layer of chocolate fudge sauce with crunchy cookies. The chocolate crunchies are the best part of an ice cream cake!

    Make Your Own Ice Cream Cake

    RED VELVET CAKE ICE CREAM – Make Your Own
    • Top Layer: Vanilla, Chocolate, Orange Chocolate
    • Bottom Layer: Vanilla, Chocolate, Orange Chocolate
    • Filling: Hot Fudge, Orange Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Caramel, Strawberry, Cherry
    • Center: Chocolate Crunchies, Crushed Peanut Butter Cups, Chopped Nuts, Crushed Oreos, Pecans, Whole Peanuts

    Platter’s ice cream cakes are great for all celebrations including parties, weddings, showers, corporate events, retirement parties, and more. We offer three different sizes. Choose a classic flavor or build your own custom ice cream cake.

    • 5 1/2 Round Cake: Serves 8-10
    • 9 Round Cake: Serves 16-18
    • 1/4 Sheet Cake: Serves 20-25

    *Please note that Ice Cream Cakes are PICK UP only and require 72 hours notice*. Provide your requested pickup date in the note section of the order. You will receive an email from Platter’s Chocolates when your order is ready for pickup. *PLEASE ALLOW 72 HOURS. IF PLACED THURSDAY AFTER 12:00pm, ORDERS WILL NOT BE COMPLETED UNTIL TUESDAY. We do have an ice cream display in store with pre-made ice cream cakes and pies, if it is outside of the order time-frame!

    Recommended Reading: Gluten And Dairy Free Cake Recipe

    Personalized Ice Cream Cakes

    If youve ever wondered to yourself, where might I find a custom ice cream cake near me? The answer is easy, with over 100 locations across Canada, Marble Slab can help you design an ice cream cake perfect for any occasion. Custom ice cream cakes are a Marble Slab specialty, as we have so many styles and flavours for you to choose from. Our custom made ice cream cakes can take the form of any of our regular cakes. You can also design an ice cream cake with a custom ice cream cake message up to 40 characters long.

    The Best Ice Cream Cake

    This is truly one of the ultimate celebrations cakes! You get four layers of distinctive decadence in each slice of cake.

    And with its combination of homemade layers and store-bought layers its simple enough yet perfectly impressive enough. The cake and whipped cream are made fresh while the ice cream and fudge sauce are store-bought to save time.

    I dont really care to admit how many slices I was able to polish off within a weeks time. Lets just say this cake is dangerously delicious!

    The chocolate cake is perfectly fudgy and you wouldnt believe how easy the batter is to make. It was inspired by my Easy Chocolate Cake but I adjusted it for a slightly smaller size and swapped buttermilk for sour cream so it didnt freeze icy.

    I recommend making the cake a day in advance so it has plenty of time to firm up completely in the freezer before serving.

    Spoil yourself this weekend with this chocolate ice cream cake, no need to wait for a birthday to make something this tempting!

    Read Also: Where To Buy The Best Carrot Cake

    Custom Made Ice Cream Cakes

    We make gluten-free cakes!! Our gluten-free cakes are made with gluten-free ice cream flavors, and we substitute chocolate crunchies with chocolate sprinkles.

    We can make Peanut-free cakes. We take peanut allergy requests very seriously. If you need a peanut-free cake, please let us know in the notes section of your order.

    Holiday delivery! We have special delivery options during the holiday season. Please inquire.

    Timing & Freezer Space

    Ice Cream Sheet Cake

    Now that weve talked about that, lets talk about how long this will take you. Making an ice cream cake is not a lot of work I dare say its easier than a baked cake. But it does take time almost entirely hands-off time, but still. If you want an ice cream cake for a birthday party, I would start at least three days ahead.

    You need a day to create the first layer, which has to freeze until solid. Then the next ice cream layer, and after that, it freezes overnight so its stable enough to remove the springform ring. Then you frost the cake with whipped cream, and its really best to let it sit in the freezer one more night before serving. Youre always fighting the clock when working with ice cream, so give yourself plenty of time to let things chill out between steps.

    Last but not least: freezer space. You need a lot. Enough to slide a whole sheet pan into the freezer. Upright freezers are best for this side-by-side and bottom-drawer freezers make it tough. Clear your freezer and do a test run with the pans before getting started.

    Set up your pan:

    Recommended Reading: Modern Cake Knife And Server Set

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This