Bake Me A Wish Birthday Cake

Must Try

Our Pick: We Take The Cake

Bake Me a Wish Cake Vlog

Claim To Fame: Fort Lauderdales most legendary custom-cake shop.

We Take The Cake is visited often by celebrities and luxury caterers. Their famous key lime bundt cake is one of Oprahs Favorite Things.

Image: We Take The Cake

About We Take The Cake Cakes:Quality and attention to detail are what sets this cake shop apart from the competition.

They use ingredients like whole buttermilk, fresh eggs and real butter just like grandma used to make. Experienced bakers mix every batter and frosting by hand.

This bakery knows that shipping a birthday cake is all about presentation. They go the extra mile with hand-decorated cakes and custom-designed packaging to make sure your birthday cake delivery is perfect.

They offer a variety of layer cakes as well as bundt cakes in classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, lemon, strawberry and raspberry.

Gluten-free and vegan cake options are available.

The iconic American company that offers gourmet cookie tins, baskets and gifts for shipping nationwide.

Image: Mrs. Fields

About Mrs. Fields Cakes:Not everyone is a cake fan. We can respect that! Thats why we included Mrs. Fields Giant Cookie Cakes in our list.

Each giant chocolate chip cookie cake measures 12 inches in diameter. These colossal cookie cakes are moist, chewy and made with real butter, whole eggs, and pure vanilla.

For ease of ordering, there are a variety of pre-set Happy Birthday designs. However, you can also customize your message and frosting colors.

Bake Me A Wish And The Military

The company is no stranger to donating to the military. Back in 2007, the company got together to begin their military initiative Operation: Birthday Cake. Partnering with Soldiers’ Angels, an organization that provides assistance to families of enlisted soldiers, continuing support for veterans and immediate response for families of the fallen, the company has delivered over 25,000 cakes to soldiers overseas.

Along with gourmet birthday cake delivery and the Freedom cake, Bake Me a Wish also sells a wide variety of shippable cakes and gourmet cookies to send to loved ones in the military, with greeting cards for personalization. Some items include Viennese Coffee Cake, assorted brownies, cookies, and cookies and cream brownie cake.

The jumbo brownie sampler is a good choice to feed a loved one and their buddies, featuring an 8-piece assortment of Velvet Ganache Chocolate, Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Crunch, Fudge Walnut, Iced Lemon Blondie and Raspberry Crumb.

Best For Chocolate Lovers: Carousel Cakes

Carousel Cakes

  • Only ships four days per week

If your birthday recipient loves chocolate, you may want to browse the goodies from Carousel Cakes of Nanuet, New York. Founded in 1965, Carousel is a trusted institution. The bakery’s online menu offers a large selection of cakes, 16 made with chocolate, including Chocolate Rum Cake, New York Blackout, and Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cake.

In addition to its chocolate specialties, Carousel also crafts quintessential birthday flavors like its Nonpareil “Giggle” Cake. All of Carousel’s cakes are certified kosher.

Carousel ships their cakes through Goldbelly or NYC Delivery Doorman and also has in-person sales for less money at their bakery outlet store. For example, the Chocolate Outrage Cake sells for $49 at Goldbelly and $17 at the store.

Shipments are only Monday through Friday, so we advise taking that into consideration when planning your purchase.

Also Check: Jamoca Almond Fudge Cake Baskin Robbins

Bake Me A Wish Shipping Policy

Bake Me A Wish specializes in overnight, nationwide shipping. They also guaranteed your order will arrive on time.

They will deliver to Hawaii and Alaska for an extra fee and with limited delivery days.

They are also able to ship a selection of goodies to US Military personnel across the seas stationed at US military bases .

Be sure to check out their frequently asked questions page. It covers a ton of shipping-related questions.

Get Ready For A Tiny Cake

Bake Me A Wish Golden Fudge Celebration Happy Birthday ...

I was excited to find an online option as I was running out of time for a birthday cake for my daughter. When I saw the picture of the caramel apple cake I knew I was in luck. Turns out that the cake was a lot smaller in person. To add insult to injury that send a birthday card addressed to someone else. The cake itself was ok at best. I wish that bake me a wish would have baked me a decent sized cake!!

Don’t Miss: Wilton Cake Pan Batter Amounts

Bake Me A Wish Reviews


If youre looking for a fun cake to send as a surprise gift, you cant go wrong with the Strawberry Funfetti cake. The pretty pink frosting and sprinkles will bring a smile to anyones face.

It has two layers of confetti cake with strawberry filling and frosting. The outside edge of the cake is packed with more confetti sprinkles.

It also comes with an optional little topper to highlight the occasion .

The cake comes in a colorful box along with a card you can personalize.

When youre shipping cakes across the country, the packaging is definitely important. Bake Me A Wish does not skimp when it comes to using the right materials for the job.

In fact, peeling through the multiple layers of protective packaging really kind of feels like opening a birthday present.


Bake Me A Wish has over 8,500 customer reviews on Trustpilot with an average score of 4.2 out of 5 stars. Over 80% of reviewers scored their experience as excellent or great.

The vast majority of customers rave about the excellent product quality and on time arrival. Here are a few comments from satisfied customers:

Always great product. Ive used this company for about 8 years now and everyone enjoys the goodies sent.

Great quality, delicious and great service would definitely recommend this company!! Thank you!! You made his birthday and my wish come true.

The cake was perfectly packed and delivered on time and was still fresh and delicious.

Our Pick: Magnolia Bakery

Claim to Fame: A World-Renowned Bakery Famous for Classic American Baked Goods and Desserts. The company captivated a worldwide audience after being featured on the hit TV show Sex and the City.

Image: Magnolia Bakery

About Magnolia Bakery Cakes:The company is based in New York City and also has bakeries in Los Angeles, Chicago, Boston, Washington, D.C., Dubai, Riyadh, Amman, Abu Dhabi, Manila and Doha. However, with nationwide shipping, you can order online and get your cake in the mail.

If you enjoy chocolate birthday cake, youll definitely want to check out the double chocolate and hazelnut chocolate. Both are perfect for chocolate lovers.

The confetti cake is a gourmet layer cake perfect for a party.

Each comes with an optional inscription as well as the convenient option to add on candles or a Magnolia Bakery knife to complete your birthday celebration.

Also Available From Magnolia Bakery:Order world-famous banana pudding, the famous Carrie Cupcakes, brownies, cookies, seasonal sweet treats and more. Cake delivery is via Goldbelly.

You May Like: Whole Foods Baby Shower Cake

Bake Me A Wish Helps Families Send Birthday Cakes To Soldiers In Iraq Elsewhere

  • 0

Imagine this: You’re on a military base in the Iraq desert.

The sun is beating overhead, and the sand is blowing in yourface. You’re hot and dirty and hungry and sweaty with all the gearon your back. It’s your 25th birthday — and you’re half a worldaway from home, thinking about the family you wish you could becelebrating with.

Suddenly, you’re greeted with a fudgy cookies-and-cream browniecake, covered with chunks of Oreo cookies and drizzled with whitechocolate, topped with a decadent piece of Belgian chocolate.

Sounds about as likely as a pig flying over the desert.

But the scenario is happening, thanks to Bake Me A Wish, agourmet baking company founded in 2004 in New York by JoshKaye.

Growing up with a challenged background, Kaye often marveled atelaborate cakes at other children’s birthday parties, alwayslonging for one of his own.

“A birthday is something very special,” Kaye said.

“It’s a special occasion, and a cake really makes itspecial.”

Now that Kaye is a parent himself, he makes the kind of cakes hewould serve to his own kids for their birthdays.

“Cakes make us feel remembered and special,” said Kaye, notinghis gift cakes are shipped in an elegant decorative box.

Bake A Wish donates 5,000 cakes a year to sick kids through MakeA Wish. He also donates 5 percent of the online sales to thatorganization.

“I’m having a carrot cake sent,” Coleman said.

Our Pick: Davids Cookies

Bake Me a Wish The Most Convenient Way To Order Cakes & Other Baked Goods?

Claim To Fame:This company is best-known for cookies to order online for nationwide shipping.

But they offer lots more including cheesecakes, specialty desserts and delicious birthday cakes all delivered nationwide.

Image: Davids Cookies

About Davids Cookies Cakes:You cant go wrong with ordering a birthday cake from Davids. The cakes are so fresh, moist and delicious, youd never guess they were shipped to your doorstep.

The Rainbow Cake is a real show-stopper. It looks like a vanilla layer cake until you cut the first slice and reveal the colorful red, orange, yellow, green and purple cake layers. Gorgeous!

And check out some of these other flavors: Mile High Peanut Butter Explosion, Chocolate Overload, Milky Caramel Galaxy, Premier Pumpkin Spice and Chocolate Chip Deep Dish Cookie Cake!

Also Available from Davids Cookies:Order cookies, brownies, cookie dough, cheesecakes, tarts, gluten-free and sugar-free treats and much more.

Also Check: Flutes And Cake Server Set

Most Festive: Milk Bar

  • Only two cake options

Are you looking for a cake that delivers the ultimate birthday essence? Check out Milk Bars birthday cakes. There are two choices: birthday cake, chocolate birthday cake, plus gluten-free versions.

But what Milk Bars menu lacks in breadth it more than makes up for with depth of craft. The website describes how the Milk Bar team worked for more than two yearsled by founder and James Beard award-winning pastry chef Christina Tosito achieve the perfect nostalgic birthday funfetti flavor. With that kind of commitment and attention to detail, it is no wonder that Milk Bar has garnered heaps of positive press and hundreds of enthusiastic customer reviews.

Prices start at $52, plus shipping for the 6-inch birthday cake. Milk Bar also offers birthday gift sets that include additional items such as cake truffles, cookies, Milk Bar pie, and Christina Tosis book, “All About Cake”. You can order ahead and even select a specific delivery day up to 30 days in advance.

Recomended Bake Me A Cake Book For Beginner

Buy Bake Me a Cake. 8601404257926 from Amazons Book Store. Bake me a cake book.

Bake Me A Cake Book, Bake me a Cake Whitley Bay. Scrumptious Bakes for Anytime Any Place. Mirandas tried-and-tested recipes are so simple to follow and dont require any specialist equipment.

Open Mon-Sat for appointments. Theres Always Time for Cake. Download Bake Me A Cake As Fast As You Can books Miranda whips up over 100 very delicious cakes traybakes and cupcakes proving how quick and easy baking can be. The Ultimate Bakers.

Don’t Miss: Tilt N Turn Ultra Cake Turntable

Best For Foodies: Goldbelly

  • Shipping times vary by bakeries’ locations

Goldbellys curated online marketplace is a hub of North Americas most notable culinary creations. The company says they believe in the power of food and its ability to bring comfort and connection. The marketplace features items like St-Viateurs bagels from Montreal, Pie Holes from Los Angeles, and a whole lot more gourmet and specialty items. When youre shopping for that iconic birthday cake for a foodie in your life, Goldbelly is the place to start.

Their website or smartphone app offers cakes from many of Americas leading bakeries such as Ovenly, Carlos, Gambinos, Carousel, We Take the Cake, and Carolines. Many bakeries, such as Red Truck, sell online exclusively through Goldbelly.

Goldbelly facilitates the ordering and shipping process, in many cases with free shipping. A few shops do charge an extra shipping fee and you can pay for faster shipping. The prices of cakes vary a lot depending on the cake and shop. However, given that this is a specialty and gourmet service, it is not always the cheapest option. Goldbellys offers an extensive selection with something for everyone, including vegan, paleo, kosher, and even gluten-free cakes.

The company ships to all 50 states and shipping times vary, as many bakeries only ship on certain days of the week.

Company Replacing Melted Cake Hooray

Bake Me A Wish Golden Fudge Celebration Cake w/ Confetti ...

Received a gift Birthday cake yesterday. I was gone all afternoon and didn’t arrive home until 10 pm. My box was left on a black trash bin by door . I live in FL. The ice was completely melted. Threw in freezer but feel probably unsafe to eat. What a waste.The company has since reached out to me post review, and I am having a new one sent on a day that I will be home. So looking forward to the chocolate Birthday cake as previous one was melted.

Reply from Bake Me A Wish

Dear Laura, Thank you for your Trust Pilot review. Please feel free to contact our Customer Service Department and one of our representatives would be happy to help rectify this with you. Thank you and have a wonderful day.Kind regards,

Don’t Miss: Nothing Bundt Cakes Gluten Free Ingredients List

Our Pick: Bake Me A Wish

Claim To Fame: Gourmet cakes and bakery gifts are delivered overnight, nationwide. Each mail order cake is delivered in an elegant gift box with a greeting card.

Image: Bake Me A Wish

About Bake Me A Wish Cakes:Bake Me A Wish doesnt stop at traditional vanilla and chocolate birthday cake flavors. This is the place to go if youre looking for a wide variety of flavor options.

Here are just a few that may strike your fancy: Tiramisu Classico, Salted Caramel, Tres Leches, Vesuvius , Butterscotch Pudding, Limoncello, Boston Cream and Coconut Cream. Yum!

Also Available from Bake Me A Wish:Cupcakes, cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, pies, gift towers and baskets filled with treats

I Ordered Christmas Deserts To Be

I ordered Christmas deserts to be delivered to my brothers house. I never felt embarrassed before when people tried them and said ” we know where not to go”. The cupcakes were so dry, and they were the mini ones. The cookies broke into pieces and the brownies tasted old not moist. I sent them an email on their site, they never responded, I asked for a refund of the products..No repsonse. I also ordered cheesecake which was edible..So I was not asking for a refund there. First time using them

You May Like: Wilton Half Sheet Cake Pan

Bake Me A Wish Gourmet Cakes: Chocolate Mousse Torte Review

By Dena

This post may contain affiliate links and/or Amazon affiliate links I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details.

Bake Me a Wish! is the premium nationwide service for delivery of gourmet birthday cakes. Their cakes are made with only the finest, freshest ingredients by an award-winning, family-run New York bakery! Bake Me A Wish! Gourmet Cakes

I just received the Chocolate Mousse Torte from Bake Me A Wish! just two days ago and it is already gone. Dont worry Nutrisystem, I had but 1 piece! I am not a big chocolate cake fan but this cake was great.

It arrived in a cool box and it was frozen. I let it thaw by sitting out for a few hours before we tried it. It just looks so decadent. So mouthwatering. So much chocolaty goodness! This cake is very rich, with two chocolate cake layers that are filled with luscious chocolate whipped cream mousse, then covered with milk chocolate frosting and a dark chocolate glaze. It is then garnished with fudge rosettes and dark chocolate shaves. It also includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Occasion Plaque, which you are able to choose the occasion that is needed.

I gave several pieces to my mom who said, Another cake is needed to further properly taste test! My son said, thisisdelicious, as he was shoveling it in. And my husband just ate more pieces than his allotted amount so I knew he liked it. Sorry Marci, next time!

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This