Which Grocery Store Makes The Best Cakes

Must Try

Disadvantages Of Grocery Store Cakes

The BEST Grocery Store Birthday Cake (Blind Taste Test)

While grocery store cakes do offer several advantages over cakes from individual bakeries, there are also some disadvantages to be considered. Think about:

  • Design: Although grocery store decorators do have some skills, you may not get the unique one-of-a-kind wedding cake you would from an individual cake bakery. There may be some techniques a grocery store bakery staff is not familiar with or able to create.
  • Flavors: The options for wedding cake flavors, fillings and frostings are usually limited at a grocery store. Ingredients may not be as high quality as the gourmet ones used at cake bakeries, either.
  • Delivery: Although many supermarket bakeries do deliver, not all of them offer this option. If yours doesn’t, you will need to arrange for the pickup and delivery of the cake yourself and possibly stack it, too.

These are just a few of the disadvantages when choosing a grocery store cake. Due to the different options at each grocery store, the advantages and disadvantages may vary, so it is important to check each store’s bakery wedding cake policy.

We Then Bit Into Vanilla Cupcakes From Whole Foods’ Bakery Which Were Beautifully Decorated But Had A Divisive Frosting Consistency

While these cupcakes were the most aesthetically pleasing of the bunch, taste-testers agreed that the frosting seemed more like whipped cream than a traditional cupcake topping, and that the sponge lacked moisture.

“The cake tastes more like a muffin than cake,” said one taste-tester.

Another cupcake-tester described the frosting as “fluffy and soft,” saying it had a nice, sweet taste, but they agreed it was not necessarily the thick frosting that tops most cupcakes.

Overall, our team enjoyed the flavors, but the dry cake texture and whipped frosting left the group divided.

Price: $2 for each cupcake at the time of purchase.

Gooey Butter Cake At Park Avenue Coffee St Louis Missouri

Gooey butter cake was created by accident in the 1940s, when St. Louis baker Johnny Hoffman used the wrong proportions to make cake batter. The irresistibly delicious mistake can now be found all over town, including at Lafayette Square’s Park Avenue Coffee, where siblings Dale Schotte and Marilyn Scull serve up their moms recipe. More than 70 flavors are available, including seasonal twists like eggnog and pumpkin caramel, but Moms Traditional is a must for those trying the buttery-crusted specialty for the first time.

Also Check: Sam’s Club Cakes Wedding

Cheesecake At Suzy’s Cream Cheesecakes Oak Creek Wisconsin

Its no surprise that dairy country would be home to excellent cheesecakes. When baker Suzy Strothmann started making them for her husbands Milwaukee restaurant in the 1980s, only local cream cheese was used, a tradition that continues today even as Suzys Cream Cheesecakes has grown from one storefront and flavor to a nationally shipping business with multiple variations on its signature cake.

Moravian Sugar Cake At Winkler Bakery Winston

The 5 Best Grocery Store Cakes You Can Buy

The Winkler Bakery has been slinging this unassumingly rich cake since the early 1800s, when Swiss-born baker Christian Winkler took over the Old Salem shop. The 200-year-old wood-fired dome oven is still in use today, churning out sheets of the eggy cake studded with buttery pockets of cinnamon and sugar.

You May Like: Wedding Cake Steps For Inground Pool

The Best Cheesecakes In America

You cant talk about New York Citystyle cheesecake without mentioning Eileens. The owner is an institution, making classic cheesecakes from her SoHo shop since 1975. She makes her light and creamy cakes in over 40 flavorsa new one added each yearwith at least 25 flavors on the menu at all times. From Mandarin Orange Marble to Makers Mark to Sugar-Free Rocky Road, Eileen has you covered. She even insists that she will do her best to accommodate a special flavor not on the menu. If you cant decide between the 20, theres a sampler plate. And Eileens ships nationwide via FoodyDirect, so no matter where you are you can enjoy a slice of NYCs original. eileenscheesecake.com

While Kristen D. Murray was pastry chef at Aquavit, then-head chef Marcus Samuelsson encouraged her to develop her own unique approach to cooking. The result: Black Pepper Cheesecake, which Murray says epitomizes her whimsical style. I like the juxtaposition of a light cheesecake with hand-cracked pepper to further help digestion and cut the fat that most associate with cheesecake, she says. Murrays recipe uses equal parts cream cheese and homemade crème fraîche, lemon juice, vanilla and aquavit. Its always on the menu at her luncheonette, MÅURICE. mauricepdx.com

Lightest And Fluffiest Yellow Cake: Pillsbury

When you need a good cake mix, dont hesitate to grab one of the biggest brands in the aisle! Pillsbury yellow cake mix produced a light and airy cake that was also perfectly moistquite the difficult balance to strike. When it came to flavor, Pillsbury delivered. Our Test Kitchen thought this sponge had that great buttery taste that you want from a yellow cake along with a hint of vanilla to give it just a bit more complexity. You cant beat this brand for a tender, flavorsome cake, one that will serve as a great foundation for all kinds of desserts.

Baking big shot Betty Crockers yellow cake mix produced a light and airy cake with a beautiful golden hue. This brand also offered a good buttery flavor and a nice sweetness that makes you think of a traditional birthday cake. This is a great option for kids cakes especially. You can turn it into your own version of a confetti cake by tossing your favorite sprinkles right into the batter.

You May Like: Wedding Cake Steps For A Pool

Best For Chocolate Lovers: Carousel Cakes

Carousel Cakes

  • Only ships four days per week

If your birthday recipient loves chocolate, you may want to browse the goodies from Carousel Cakes of Nanuet, New York. Founded in 1965, Carousel is a trusted institution. The bakery’s online menu offers a very large selection of cakes, 15 of which are packed with chocolate, including German chocolate cake, New York blackout, and rocky road.

In addition to its chocolate specialties, Carousel also crafts quintessential birthday flavors like its nonpareil giggle cake and sprinkle happy cake. All of Carousel’s cakes are certified kosher.

Carousel ships their cakes through Goldbelly and also has in-person sales for less money at their bakery outlet store. For example, the chocolate outrage cake sells for $49 dollars at Goldbelly and $17 at the store.

Shipments are only Tuesday through Friday, so plan ahead.

Layered Grocery Store Cake Trifle

Who Makes The Best Wedding Cake? Candid Competition

Theres no rule that says that grocery store cake has to stay intact. You can totally use it to layer a brilliant dessert with this berry trifle. Trifles are easy to make and of course, delicious. Youll need fruit and pudding in whatever flavor you want cheesecake or French vanilla work really well. Strawberries, blueberries and other fruits can be used and you can use any number of cake flavors depending on your fruit choice and what your grocery store may have on sale.

Recipe/Tutorial: lifeloveandsugar

Don’t Miss: Where Can You Buy Cake Pops

Red Velvet Cheesecake At The Rabbit Hole Bakery Lincoln Nebraska

If its name doesnt give away its inspiration, then the decor probably will: The quaint Rabbit Hole Bakery in Lincoln, Nebraska, is adorned with antique clocks, teapots and colorful books, a nod to baker Amanda Fuchsers love of Alice in Wonderland. Her exquisite desserts would be a hit at any Mad Hatter tea party especially the red velvet cheesecake, a scarlet confection that gets its distinctive tang from buttermilk, sour cream and vinegar.

How Do You Make A Dry Cake Moist

How to Moisten a Cake After Baking

  • Mix equal parts of sugar and water in a saucepan. Start with 1/4 cup each of water and sugar.
  • Heat the sugar and water mixture over medium-high heat until it comes to a boil.
  • Use a bamboo skewer to poke holes in the top of the cake.
  • Spread the simple syrup over the top of the cake with a pastry brush.
  • Cover the cake.
  • You May Like: Wedding Cake Steps For A Pool

    Ultimate Coconut Cake At Peninsula Grill Charleston South Carolina

    The coconut cake at this fine-dining destination made its debut as a Valentines Day special in 1997. But the 12-layer cake made such an impression that its been on the menu ever since. Available by the slice at the restaurant , the lofty confection with six thin layers of cake separated by six layers of cream cheese frosting has won the hearts of locals and celebrities alike.

    Fabulous Vegan Cakes You Can Pick Up At The Grocery Store

    Pictures Of Cakes From Grocery Stores

    There are countless ways to come by a vegan cakehomemade, semi-homemade , local vegan bakeries, cakes that shipbut the fastest way to get a cake onto your table is to purchase one from the grocery store. Youre already there for tofu and kale, so you might as well pick up an impulse-buy cake. Different supermarkets carry different brands, but you can expect to find at least one of these grab-and-go desserts at a grocer near you. Candles are optional.

    View this post on Instagram

    1. Just DessertsWhether youre a chocolate or vanilla fan, Just Desserts has a wonderfully moist cake for any occasion. The two six-inch vegan cake options include a decadent Vegan Midnight Chocolate Cake and a decorative Chocolate Dipped Vanilla Bundt Cake. Afraid of what might happen if left alone in your apartment with an entire cake? Opt for the single-serving chocolate or vanilla vegan cupcakes . Where to find Just Desserts: Kroger , Albertsons, Costco, Target, Whole Foods, and more.

    View this post on Instagram

    View this post on Instagram

    View this post on Instagram

    View this post on Instagram

    View this post on Instagram

    Get the Holiday Food Issue of VegNews FREE when you subscribe by November 1!

    You May Like: Oreo Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Cake Baskin Robbins

    Who Makes The Best Grocery Store Sheet Cake

    Indeed, a slice of baked batter topped with frosting is a requisite piece of any celebration, from a birthday bash to an office occasion.

    Grocers are keen to be part of Americas parties. Many are investing in their in-store bakeries, both as a way to appear fresh in the eyes of consumers and as a means to keep you in their aisles. Buying a cake from a baker instead of a cooler case adds value to the shopping experience.

    And bakeries add to grocers bottom line. Americans spent $13.5 billion on in-store bakery products in 2015, according to Progressive Grocers 2016 Retail Bakery Review.

    The Republic‘s Food & Dining team wondered which grocery store bakery makes the best cake, so we hosted a taste test of sheet cakes.

    Store Bought Cake With Added Fruit

    Something as simple as adding fresh fruit can instantly dress up that plain store bought cake and make it spectacular. You dont even need that much fruit or that much time for this one. Just choose your fruit strawberries, bananas, kiwi, etc. and then layer it in whatever design you want. This is an excellent idea for summer parties and barbecues or you could use flowers as well to give that grocery store cake a makeover.

    Recipe/Tutorial: thehouseofsilverlining

    Read Also: Wedding Cake Steps For A Pool

    Betty Crocker Super Moist Cake Mixes

    Betty Crockers been killing the boxed-cake-mix game for decades, and the Super Moist version, widely available in grocery stores throughout the U.S., received enthusiastic accolades from several of the pastry chefs we interviewed.

    Executive pastry chef Amanda Rose of Desserts First in Castro Valley, California, explains why the brands Super Moist mix deserves attention: This particular type of Betty Crocker cake mix has pudding in the mix, which helps retain the liquid on the cake and makes for a more moist end product.

    Executive pastry chef Emily Bailey of the Red South Beach Hotel in Miami Beach, Florida, gives a special shout-out to the Carrot Cake flavor of Super Moist mix, telling HuffPost, This is my favorite because even by itself without any enhancements, its great. To make this cake feel like its actually homemade, I add a few special ingredients. I add 2 cups of peeled, grated carrots, 1/2 cup chopped, strained fresh pineapple, 1/4 cup of coconut flakes, and a tablespoon of cinnamon. All of these additions make the cake really feel like you just spent hours baking it, but in reality, it only took half an hour. To make it even greater, make your own cream cheese icing instead of using store-bought!

    Are Walmart Cakes Good

    Turning $3 Grocery Store Cupcakes into Boujee CAKE TRUFFLES!

    If you are planning a kids birthday party, Walmart is definitely the one-stop-shop.

    You can purchase your presents, party supplies, decorations, and yes, even your cake at Walmart.

    Talk about convenient!

    But how good are their cakes? Good is really subjective, but for clarity, Im assuming we can agree that moist cakes are better than dry cakes. Lets also assume that frosting that hurts your teeth is too sweet.

    Walmart does not have a terribly wide selection of cake flavors. The following are available at most stores:

    • White cake

    Yellow cake is available at select stores.

    Most enormous slices of cake at this grocery store

    Elizabeth West

    I found several reviews of Walmart cakes that have similar themes. Reviewers say they do not have a wide selection of cakes, and they sometimes dont look like they are supposed to.

    Generally speaking, I find the frosting is too sweet, but the cake itself is moist and tasty. As an added bonus, Walmarts cakes are very affordable. Just like pretty much everything else at Walmart.

    So if you arent looking for anything fancy, and just want inexpensive cake, Walmart is probably a good option.

    If this is your childs first birthday, theyll even give you a free smash cake with a cake purchase of at least $15.

    A smash cake is a cake specifically for the birthday boy or girl to smash and play in without getting their kid germs all over the big cake.

    Its actually pretty fun to watch your new 1-year-old dig into their very own cake!

    Recommended Reading: Above Ground Pool Wedding Cake Steps

    Supermarket Wedding Cake Is Budget

    In all fairness, you cant get the something as custom as a custom designed cake from a specialized bakery. Custom bakers are not just making cakes, they are making edible art. So if you want to wow the guests with something that can be displayed at the museum, with intricate details and finest ingredients. If you are looking for quality and focused attention on your wedding cake, be prepared to pay the price. However, if you are on a tight budget, we recommend that you take a look at the possibility of ordering wedding cake from a grocery store. You will get a beautiful cake and the sweet taste of savings as a bonus!

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This