Reeses Premium Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cake
If youve got peanut butter cup lovers in your house, this is the ice cream cake for them. A layer of peanut butter cups runs through the chocolate ice cream base, which is iced with whipped peanut butter frosting, and decorated with an extra drizzle of fudge sauce and crushed peanut butter cups. The chocolate ice cream wasnt as rich as the one in the basic Carvel cake, but I think thats actually a good thing. Peanut butter and chocolate desserts can sometimes be super rich and almost too decadent. This option felt balanced. The marbled chocolate drizzle over the top is a nice touch and feels a little more elevated. This was my 14-year-old sons choice, and likely a good bet if youre serving a bunch of teens.
Buy: Reeses Premium Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cake, $14.98 for 46 ounces at Walmart
How To Order A Customsundae Ice Cream Cake
It’s easy! Just call your nearest Sundae location or stop in to place your order.
Orders must be placed a minimum of 72 hours or 7 days in advance, depending on location.Please see locations below for more information.
Need it sooner? Grab a freshly made ice cream cake, hand-packed pints, and artisan ice cream sandwiches from the Joy-To-Go case at your local Sundae scoop shop.
Store At Room Temperature In An Airtight Container
If you bake or buy a freshly-baked cake one night with plans to serve it the following day, you should be fine with storing it in its box or in a sealed plastic container in a cool, dark corner of your kitchen counter.
If you want to be particularly diligent about keeping your cake fresh, store it in a positively airtight container. If it came in a nice cardboard box that you dont want to undo, wrap the box in plastic wrap. If you made the cake, seal it in a plastic cake storage container.
Store your cake at room temperature and keep it out of the direct sun and away from any major heat sources that might melt the icing.
Keep your cake boxed on the counter for up to three days.
A sponge cake can be stored in a sealed, airtight container at room temperature for about three days. I have friends who have nommed on cakes for up to five days!
Also Check: What Is Red Velvet Cake Made Of
Custom Sheet Cake 1 Layer Full Sheet
This is similar to the cakes listed above.
As is the same with the last cake, this one varies in price and size.
The full sheet will be able to serve 50-60 people. This is, by far, the largest option for a single-layered custom sheet cake.
This price is roughly 47 dollars, again depending on customization.
This is also available to order online.
How To Order Your Perfect Stop And Shop Cakes
Stop and Shop does pick-up only. The process for ordering your cake is streamlined and easy to understand.
First, go to their official website. There, you hover the mouse pointer over the Shop tab. From the drop-down menu, click on the Catering tab and you will be redirected to the Entertaining Orders section.
You can only use this service if you live in one of the states this company is based in. If you do however, start off by picking the state and city that is closest to you for pick up.
Once you have found the store nearest to you, choose what kind of cake you are looking for. We will go in depth on the types of cakes Stop& Shop offers in another section of this post.
Most of the cakes that you will end up choosing require that you call the store. All with the exception of a few are highly customizable, meaning you get to specify exactly what it is that you want.
You will be given the number of the store for the pick-up when placing the final order.
If you are getting a cake with a set design, then you can place your order online without any phone call and pay right then and there. It all depends on what you are looking for and how detailed you want your order to be.
That is all you need to place an order! Stop and Shop bakeries have been in the catering business for a long time, so they know the best way to ensure that placing an order with them is easy and convenient for all of their customers.
Also Check: Where Can I Get A Cookie Cake
This Is A More Traditional Birthday Cake Depending On How You Customize It
It is round, and you have the choice between yellow cake, chocolate, or marble. You can get traditional ice cream, or you can also get whipped cream for a lighter option.
You can also choose the filling you want to be in between the two layers.
If you are ordering you need at least 2 days notice for the item to be baked and customized.
This is something you can order online. The cake costs roughly 17 dollars.
Will Cake Mold If Left Out
If youre worried about cakes getting moldy, dont. Ive kept cupcakes around to see what happens to them, and they dont grow mould. They just dry out and harden. They actually become rather cute fossils that make for excellent projectile weapons. Nobody would expect a cupcake to be as hard as a rock, which makes your attack all the more surprising and wonderfully painful.
Don’t Miss: Where To Buy Wedding Cake Knife Set
How To Store A Cake Overnight
Most cakes will do fine left in the bakery box on the kitchen counter. You can wrap the outside of the box with plastic wrap for extra moisture retention. You can also use an airtight container.
Note:
These rules do not apply to custom-decorated wedding cakes, which tend to be more labor-intensive to create and are not really about flavor anyway.
Custom Sheet Cake 1 Layer Sheet
These cakes serve 20-24 people. You can put any sort of personalized message on the cake that is less than 10 words.
You get to choose what kind of cake you want, the icing type and the color of the decorations/lettering color.
You will also need to allow 2 days notice for this item. It will cost you roughly 35 dollars depending on what filling and icing you use.
This is an item you can order online.
Recommended Reading: How To Make Icing For Cake
Custom Sheet Cakes With Filling
These are just generic sheet cakes that you can have completely customized to your specifications.
For the filling, you can choose between fruit, puddings, whipped white or chocolate frosting, real whipped cream, or traditional white or chocolate frosting.
You cant order this cake online as it so strongly depends on what it is you want as the customer.
Prices are not listed on the website. It is suggested you call your local store and allow two days before picking up this item.
Berry Banana Pudding Ice Cream Cake
- Prep time20mins
Fruit preserves and fresh berries bring festive color to this Southern-inspired no-cook summer dessert, making it great for the Fourth of July.
Add ingredients to cart
- ½ box vanilla wafer cookies
- 1 box instant vanilla pudding mix
- 1 ¾ cups low-fat milk, cold
- 2 small bananas, peeled and chopped
- 2 ½ cups vanilla ice cream, softened
- cup blueberry preserves
- Fresh blueberries and raspberries, for garnish
Also Check: Kodiak Cakes Super Fruit Syrup Costco
Why You Shouldnt Refrigerate Your Cake
I always used to refrigerate cake, probably because we have been conditioned to believe that all things are kept fresh in the refrigerator. For many years, I believed that this was a good practice, not only because one generally puts things in the refrigerator but also because I frequently see cakes displayed in refrigerators and refrigerated cases in many cafes and restaurants.
My entire belief system was turned upside down when I had my first day of work at a famous DC cupcake shop. When I asked them how to store some of the cupcakes I was taking home at the end of the night and suggested refrigeration in an airtight container, they looked at me like I had just proposed we cook and eat a newborn baby.
This is because my coworkers and bosses took cake and cupcakes very seriously. And because refrigeration is a dreadful thing to inflict on a perfectly good cake.
Why? Refrigeration dries sponge cakes out. Its that simple.
Even if you refrigerate a cake in a perfectly sealed container and only for a short amount of time, it will dry out. The only time it is appropriate to refrigerate a cake is if it has decorative buttercream icing that is literally melting or if it is not a sponge cake and rather a cheesecake or some sort of mousse that does require refrigeration.
Try to think of sponge cake like bread. After all, the two things are quite similar. Do you put your bread in the fridge? No. So dont put your cake in the fridge either!
Dont refrigerate me!!!
Carvel Ice Cream Cakes
Stop & Shop dont post on their website how much these cakes cost. These are just traditional ice cream cakes that you can pick up at any of their grocery store locations.
Taking their other cake prices into consideration, these probably run up to about 15-20 dollars each.
If you want this customized for an event, like a name or short phrase put on the top of the cake, take it to the baker in the actual store and they will customize it for free.
You are not getting any super fancy customizations with this option, but it is a great last-minute option when you are on your way to the party.
You cant order this cake online.
Read Also: Nothing Bundt Cakes Red Velvet Bundtini
Stop And Shop Cakes Prices And How To Order
Looking to place an order for a custom cake online? Want something unique for an event but only have time to pick it up at the store?
Stop and Shop is a great option. This company is a large grocery store chain that specializes in providing a complete experience for their customers.
They deliver groceries, floral arrangements, pharmaceuticals, and make custom order cakes that fit every specification. Stop & Shop supermarkets can be found in several states, including but not limited to New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut.
They also offer various platter arrangements, such as sandwiches or wraps, that would complement any event.
If you are looking to just order a unique cake for someones birthday, wedding, or other similar event, then this article will guide you through the entire ordering process with Stop and Shop.
It will also go over cake prices and what options are available for you as a customer.
So, lets dive into how you might get those tasty, mouth-watering Stop and Shop cakes.
Custom Sheet Cake 2 Layer Sheet
Just like the single layered cakes, this order gives you the option of choosing what type of cake you have, the icing and decoration color.
This also has a limit of the personalized message being 10 words or less.
The two layered cakes also require at least a two days notice in order to complete the order.
This will serve 35-40 people, depending on how hungry they are, and will cost you roughly 48 dollars.
This is also able to order online.
You May Like: Nothing Bundt Cake Red Velvet Recipe
Some Popular Flavor Combinations Include:
- Birthday Cake Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles mixed in and Yellow Cake on the bottom
- Cheesecake Ice Cream with Strawberries and Graham Cracker Crumble mixed in and Yellow Cake on the bottom
- Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Cookie Pieces and Cookie Dough Mixed in and Yellow Cake on the bottom
- Chocolate Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Cups mixed in and Chocolate Cake on the Bottom
- Ice Cream Flavor #1: Espresso, Ice Cream Flavor #2: Mint Cocoa Nib Chip With Chocolate Cake On The Bottom
How To Store Cakes: Advice From A Pro
Simone spent a year working at a famous cupcake shop where she learned from the experts.
The best way to store a cake to keep it fresh.
Cake storage is not the clear-cut process you thought it was, believe me. As a lifelong cake aficionado and fangirl, I thought I knew everything there was to know about cake preparation and storage. But I was wrong.
When I spent about a year working at a famous Washington, D.C. cupcake shop and learning from the experts, I acquired a great deal of knowledge about the less-than-obvious process of successful cake storage.
Below, I shall share my insider knowledge on how to store cakes. Ill dispel the myths, share my secrets, and help you decide on how to best store a cake based on your estimated time of eating.
You May Like: Cake Stairs For Above Ground Pool
Don’t Miss: How To Make Homemade Ice Cream Cake
Freeze For Longterm Storage
If you know that you want to serve a cake more than three days after its baking, seal it in an airtight container and freeze it. When youre ready to eat it, let thaw it slowly at room temperature.
Freezing helps seal the moisture in, whereas refrigerating dries things out. The area of any cake that is most negatively impacted by freezing is the icing, as icing does not thaw out looking as perky as it did when it was first applied. That said, freezing results in a far more tasty cake than one that has gone stale and dryeither at room temperature or in a refrigerator.
Sealed containers are best.
You May Like: Stairs Wedding Cake
Jon Donaire Mudd Pie Ice Cream Cake
This cake was a significant departure from the other two. As a coffee ice cream lover, I was immediately intrigued by the idea of a cake made up of coffee-flavored ice cream rippled with chocolate and toasted almonds on a fudge-topped chocolate cookie crust. This was definitely a more sophisticated ice cream cake, including the more careful packaging to preserve the presentation. My favorite part was the cookie crust. It brought a little nostalgia to the whole thing, which made it fun to eat. If I needed a quick grocery store dessert for an event, I wouldnt hesitate to stop and pick one of these up. My husband was definitely also a fan.
Buy: Jon Donaire Mudd Pie Ice Cream Cake mine cost $14.81 when I ordered it via Amazon. Its no longer available there, but you can buy it at Instacart, where prices vary by location.
Is there a store-bought ice cream cake that you swear by? Tell us about it in the comments below!
Don’t Miss: Dairy And Soy Free Cake Recipe