Which Grocery Store Has The Best Birthday Cakes

Must Try

I Am A Baby Name Expert

The BEST Grocery Store Birthday Cake (Blind Taste Test)

Winco also had a decent cake, Allen said, considering it arrives at the store frozen but fully assembled and frosted.

It makes for a great last-minute option if you’re in a bind and in need of a cake.

The Whole Foods cake, while beautiful, had a significant flaw in its buttercream. Allen claimed the butter flavor was very overpowering.

This cake was also the most expensive of the six, making it a last resort option – unless you pre-order and opt for a different frosting.

The Kroger cake was uneven and lacking flavor, Allen said.

Walmart provided another reliable option at a reasonable price. But be prepared for overly sweet frosting.

Best Places To Order Birthday Cakes

by | Jan 20, 2017 | Birthday Cakes

It is quite surprising to some people that local grocery stores produce fantastic birthday cakes. Often culinary school graduates will begin working in the bakery of a nearby grocery store and hone their skills providing the rest of us with beautifully decorated cakes. Alternatively, the established baker will take young people in and apprentice them in the art of cake decorating. That is why grocery and warehouse stores make up this list of the best places to order birthday cakes. Let us consider their prices, designs, and delivery timelines.

Jon Donaire Mudd Pie Ice Cream Cake

This cake was a significant departure from the other two. As a coffee ice cream lover, I was immediately intrigued by the idea of a cake made up of coffee-flavored ice cream rippled with chocolate and toasted almonds on a fudge-topped chocolate cookie crust. This was definitely a more sophisticated ice cream cake, including the more careful packaging to preserve the presentation. My favorite part was the cookie crust. It brought a little nostalgia to the whole thing, which made it fun to eat. If I needed a quick grocery store dessert for an event, I wouldnt hesitate to stop and pick one of these up. My husband was definitely also a fan.

Buy: Jon Donaire Mudd Pie Ice Cream Cake mine cost $14.81 when I ordered it via Amazon. Its no longer available there, but you can buy it at Instacart, where prices vary by location.

Is there a store-bought ice cream cake that you swear by? Tell us about it in the comments below!

Don’t Miss: Nothing Bundt Cakes Kansas City Mo

Eat This Not That Verdict:

After putting out 80 cupcakes during prime snack time , Pillsburys batch were the last cupcakes left standing. If youre a die-hard fan of artificially-colored cake mix, for the same nutritionals, similar ingredients, and a better taste, we recommend going with our #2 pick, which youll read more about below.

If you are planning a kids birthday party, Walmart is definitely the one-stop-shop.

You can purchase your presents, party supplies, decorations, and yes, even your cake at Walmart.

Talk about convenient!

But how good are their cakes? Good is really subjective, but for clarity, Im assuming we can agree that moist cakes are better than dry cakes. Lets also assume that frosting that hurts your teeth is too sweet.

Walmart does not have a terribly wide selection of cake flavors. The following are available at most stores:

Yellow cake is available at select stores.

Most enormous slices of cake at this grocery store

Elizabeth West

I found several reviews of Walmart cakes that have similar themes. Reviewers say they do not have a wide selection of cakes, and they sometimes dont look like they are supposed to.

Generally speaking, I find the frosting is too sweet, but the cake itself is moist and tasty. As an added bonus, Walmarts cakes are very affordable. Just like pretty much everything else at Walmart.

So if you arent looking for anything fancy, and just want inexpensive cake, Walmart is probably a good option.

What To Know Before Ordering

Pictures Of Cakes From Grocery Stores: Photo

First things first, its important to remember that ordering your wedding cake in advance is crucial. While grocery store bakeries may not need a whole years notice, its best to order at least four months in advance. This will give the bakery department time to be sure all materials are on-hand at the store, along with managing any scheduling needs to accommodate your request.

The options for ordering a grocery store wedding cake are typically limited. You will have a few flavor choices, such as chocolate or vanilla cake. Depending on the store, there might be additional options for filling flavors, along with frosting choices.

In choosing the decorations for your wedding cake, its best to keep things simple or choose a design from the bakerys lookbook as decorators are specifically trained for those designs. If youre hoping for a plain, frosted cake, or a cake with a hint of texture, grocery store cakes are a great option. “Publix reviews the most popular trends every year and creates new designs about every 12 to 18 months,” shares Brous. Remember, if you opt for simplicity, you can also dress the cake up further on your own by adding a topper or fresh blooms.

If you plan to top your cake with flowers, be sure to let your florist know. They can add cake flowers to your final order so you’ll have fresh blooms that match your wedding’s palette.

Also Check: Skinnypop Popcorn Mini Cakes Cinnamon And Sugar

Which Supermarket Does The Best Birthday Cakes

While we all know that homemade cake is the best, sometimes its just not feasible.

If you have a local bakery nearby, sometimes it can be even better than homemade. But if you dont have a local bakery, supermarkets are all over the place. Chances are that your local supermarket sells cakes. Some even bake them in-house.

But again, best is subjective and it depends on who the cake is for.

As well get more into below, a childs first birthday is about the parents having fun not the quality of the cake. For that, Walmart wins as theyll give you a smash cake for free if youre spending at least $15 bucks.

Target wins for kids ages 5-10 as they do a lot of licensed character cakes . But not all locations have a bakery.

For a very large group , its hard to beat Costco for the size and price.

But if what youre wanting is a really high-quality cake made from quality ingredients, its almost impossible to beat Whole Foods Market.

Any Good Grocery Store Birthday Cakes

May 12th, 2017 9:17 am

Sask.

May 12th, 2017 9:27 am

+1

May 12th, 2017 9:35 am

+2

akswun wrote: Costco all DAY! If you’re planning on having the party this weekend you better get your request in. Otherwise you can just grab one of the cakes they have available. I think they’re like $20 and they taste amazing!

+1

Kiraly wrote: Do you want it to just look good, or does it have to taste good?I no longer buy disgusting birthday cakes from Safeway and the like. I now get them at Whole Foods. They don’t cost as much as you might think and the quality is definitely worth it.

natalka wrote: Here, our Safeway makes fab cakes – especially Black Forest cake, and carrot cake – I’ve had those as slab cakes.I’ve also had their really good lemon cake, and German chocolate cake – as layer cakes. Not sure if they make those in slab form.

akswun wrote: Costco all DAY! If you’re planning on having the party this weekend you better get your request in. Otherwise you can just grab one of the cakes they have available. I think they’re like $20 and they taste amazing!

nfox420 wrote: I read some reviews of costco’s cakes and some people have said they are either really amazing or really bad , my budget is $50- do you know if costco has more premium cakes at a bit of a higher price?

May 12th, 2017 9:55 am

+1
Vancouver

May 12th, 2017 10:06 am

1626 upvotes

May 12th, 2017 10:24 am

GTA

May 12th, 2017 10:31 am

+3
Toronto

May 12th, 2017 10:35 am

Vancouver

May 12th, 2017 10:46 am

+1

Read Also: Open Nature Gluten Free Cake Mix

Our Favorite Places To Get Birthday Cakes In Plano And Surrounding Areas

Here is a list of some of the Plano Moms favorite places where you can order your next custom birthday cake from simple to the most creative birthday cakes all worthy of your special day.

Do you love Ice Cream? Ice Cream cakes are also great options We have 50 Great Local Ice-Cream and Fro-Yo places nearby!

What Is The Most Popular Flavor Of Birthday Cake

Turning a $20 Grocery Store Cake into a Trendy Wedding Cake!

salted caramel cakeThe most popular birthday cake flavor is salted caramel cake. As salted caramel becomes more and more popular in desserts, it makes sense that the flavor would become a popular choice for birthday cake flavors. Overall, these flavors sound more like a plated dessert than a traditional cake.

Don’t Miss: Flights From Cak To Charleston Sc

New Orleans Saints Cake Cake Decorating I Baked

Best Birthday Cakes New Orleans from New Orleans Saints cake Cake Decorating I baked. Source Image: . Visit this site for details:

Looks like youre the next Cake Manager. With 21 pieces of baking equipment, youll have everything you require to work up the ideal cake. Next time your task has a potluck, make sure to offer to bring dessert!.

While you might be utilized to the typical cake mix that originates from a box, deal with the special birthday someone right with a homemade cake. The extra action required to cheer up someones special day with the tempting Funfetti cake is specifically what a January birthday requires. For a Funfetti frosting dish, have a look at our list.

523learn more

If youre looking for the best places to order a birthday cake online for delivery, weve put together this top list just for you.

There are some amazing options when it comes to online cakes, and we only selected the best of the best.

In A Rush?chocolatesurpriseuniqueOMG

Buying a birthday cake online for delivery is easy, the hardest part is having to choose which flavor is best. So lets jump in and check out the best birthday cakes for online delivery.

You cant go wrong with Milk Bars birthday cake. Theyve spent over two years perfecting the recipe and its success is clearly visible with the thousands of reviews its achieved.

Tastes like childhood.

Milk Bar

Milk Bar offers cakes in 6-inch and 10-inch sizes and you can schedule your delivery up to 30 days in advance.

What Are The Best Luxury Layer Cakes To Order By Mail

You know what they say: let them eat cake. And even though Marie Antoinette may not be the best role model, we think she had a point. Cake is always the answer.

What are the best mail-order luxury gourmet layer cakes currently online to buy by mail?

Maybe its your birthday, or maybe its someone elses or maybe its a normal day, and you just want a bite of something sweet and delicious. That when the best luxury layer cakes by mail can come to the rescue.

Recommended Reading: Newlywed Cake Roll

You May Like: Annie’s Homegrown Certified Organic Bunny Grahams Birthday Cake

Why Is Publix Cake So Good

Its not just because of the freshness or the high-quality ingredients. Publix has been baking cakes for over 70 years, and theyve gotten good at it.

Heres why:

1 Publix has a dedicated bakery department with a team of bakers who have been trained in all aspects of baking, including how to make cakes that taste great, look amazing, and last for days after you buy them. Its no accident that Publix cake tastes so goodits the result of years of practice and expertise.

2 Publix uses high-quality ingredients like real butter, whole eggs , and pure cane sugar in their cakes. You can taste how good these things are when you eat a slice of Publix cake!

3 Publix cakes use only natural flavorings in their recipes they dont use artificial flavors or chemicals to create those delicious flavors you love!

Be Considerate With Your Cake Artist’s Work And Time

The 7 Best Birthday Cake Bakeries in NYC

When ordering a grocery store cake, be considerate of the baker’s time and energy. They deal with a lot of customers and, potentially, hate. As one Iowa-based cake designer told Insider, “The sooner, the better,” especially when it’s a personalized cake. Yes, you can order a custom cake based on your party theme or interest in a supermarket, probably with a friendlier cost, and without too many protocols. However, the artist would probably put more effort into your order if you give them more time to prepare your cake. Your celebration is two weeks from now? It’s not a bad moment to start thinking about the cake.

Every grocery store is different, so you should also adapt to their styles and needs. Nevertheless, according to The Grocery Store Guy, Target has the best cakes for children. Ultimately, be respectful, plan ahead, and let your creative side appear in the process no matter where you shop for your next cake, or browse some of the best cakes to bake for birthdays. Happy birthday to you!

You May Like: White Chocolate Raspberry Bundt Cake Nothing Bundt Cake

Did I Answer Everything You Wanted To Know About What Grocery Store Has The Best Cakes

There really are some amazing options for cakes for celebrations in a range of sizes.

Your sons first birthday may be great with a cake from Walmart and a matching smash cake. If you want something a little more grown-up, or a little more sophisticated, Whole Foods is your best bet.

And if you like to avoid artificial ingredients and preservatives as I do, Whole Foods is most certainly the way to go.

What are you celebrating?

Grocery Store Cakes Are Mostly Not Healthy

You will see that a lot of grocery store cakes taste so sweet that it literally makes you sick. Not only do they use sweetening agents but they also include food colorings, stabilizers, preservatives, and tons of other chemicals so that these cakes have a greater shelf-life.

When it comes to grocery stores, speed is of the essence. As these cakes are brought or baked in bulk, they are not fresh and have a diminished quality to them.

Moreover, these artificial measures are taken so that the appearance of these cakes is made better. As a result, the customers of the store will be charmed by the bright décor of the cakes and end up buying them.

For cakes in bakeries, that is not the case, they use real ingredients and do not keep baked goods for days at a time. They also use ingredients that are rich in quality, taste, etc. All this is because they bake their cakes when a customer places an order.

You May Like: Wild One Cake Topper Party City

Les Amis Bake Shoppe Baton Rouge La

Life-changing is what some people call eating cake at Les Amis Bake Shoppe. Located in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, this full service bakery is the place where good friends and good cake meet. Using only the best ingredients to create one-of-a-kind cakes for your special occasion, Les Amis will help you have a truly sweet celebration. Vanilla Caramel Crunch, Coconut Cream, Southern Red Velvet, Blueberry Chardonnay, Lemon Raspberry, and Strawberry Silk are just a few of the flavors offered, with their Carrot Cake being a top seller. The Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel is their signature cake. They always have cakes on site for purchase, but for specialty cakes, youll want to call ahead.

The Complete Guide To Grocery Store Wedding Cakes

Turning a $20 Grocery Store Cake into a $500 Fall Wedding Cake!

Planning your wedding comes with a long list of decisions to make, from choosing your venue and invitations to pretty florals. Included in that list of choices is what dessert you plan to serve. And while there are plenty of unique options such as cookies, churros, and cupcakes, for many, its all about serving up classic slices of wedding cake.

What if you could take much of the guesswork out of choosing your wedding cake? And better yet, save money while youre at it? For many couples, a grocery store wedding cake is the ideal solution. Grocery store bakeries may not be able to accommodate entirely elaborate designs, but there are still plenty of stunning options. Plus, it may also mean choosing a cake flavor you already know and love.

“It really isn’t about choosing a grocery store, but rather trusting a brand they have grown up with,” says Maria Brous, director of communications of Publix Super Markets. “On your special day, you want to be surrounded by family, friends, good food, and things that bring good memories.”

Meet the Expert

Maria Brous is the director of communications for Publix Super Markets.

Wondering if a cake from your favorite grocery store might be the right fit for your big day? Read on to learn all about grocery store wedding cakes in this helpful guide.

Don’t Miss: A Piece Of Cake By Cupcake Brown

Quacks 43rd St Bakery

Alright old school Austinites: who was around when this place began in 1983 on The Drag? Its been around the block! Quacks 43rd St Bakery is still turning out a massive amount of cakes, cookies, and pies from its Hyde Park storefront. The online system isnt very clear, but you can see them menu of full-size birthday cakes here, and then call the bakery and order ahead. |WEBSITE| 411 E 43rd St, Austin, TX

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This